Consistent EdgeUpdated 29 Oct 2026Account

How we test

One public rulebook for every listing. Same entry, same costs, same risk, whoever the provider is.

What we track

Every signal a group posts, captured with the time it arrived. Edits and deletions are logged, so a removed losing call still counts. History imported from before we started tracking is marked and never ranked.

How a signal is traded

We enter at the next 1-minute open after the post (about 30 seconds on average), pay the spread and commission, and use their stop and take-profits, split equally. Follow-up instructions (move stop, close half, close now) are applied when they arrive.

How results are measured

R is the distance from their quoted entry to their stop. The % figures assume 1% of the account at risk per signal. We also show the same signals with fixed lots in dollars.

What doesn't count

Signals without a stop or target, levels on the wrong side of the price, and calls where the price had already hit the stop or moved more than 1R away when the message was posted.

Ranking

A listing is ranked once it has 30 trades over 60 days of live tracking. The score weighs risk-adjusted return (30%), drawdown (20%), consistency (20%), track record (15%) and integrity (15%).

Integrity checks

We flag deleted signals, high win rates with negative expectancy, results that only work at the provider's own quoted price, signals edited after posting, and statements that don't add up.